Motley Fool CEO: Selling Winners Too Soon Is Investors' "Most Significant Mistake"
Key Takeaways
In a recent interview, The Motley Fool's CEO and co-founder, Tom Gardner, was asked what is the most significant mistake investors make. And it might be surprising to learn that...
Article Overview
Quick insights and key information
4 min read
Estimated completion
real estate
Article classification
July 9, 2025
11:36 AM
The Motley Fool
Original publisher
In a recent interview, The Motley Fool's CEO and co-founder, Tom Gardner, was asked what is the most significant mistake investors make
And it might be surprising to learn that the mistake he mentioned isn't one that involves losing money, at least in the immediate sense. "The most significant mistake that an investor makes is selling a winner too soon," Gardner said. "We don't think that because when we look at our portfolio and see a stock that's down 37%, we think 'that's the worst mistake I've made. ' I put $4,000 in it, and I lost $1,000. " Gardner went on to say that there's a far greater risk of loss when it comes to selling a winning investment too early: "The biggest loser, though, is the winner you sold too soon -- that is, the ability to take money, $10,000, and put it into Starbucks (SBUX 0. 32%) and end up with $500,000. " Image source: Getty Images
Letting your winners run, and focusing on long-term in general, are cornerstones of The Motley Fool's investment philosophy
Gardner pointed out that some of the market's biggest winners had times when they looked they had plateaued, specifically mentioning a five-year period during which heavyweight Nvidia (NVDA 1. 81%) went nowhere -- before rocketing higher
He's absolutely right
From 2010 through 2014, Nvidia duced just a 12% gain for investors in five years after nearly quintupling during the 2000s
Since that time, however, Nvidia has been up by 33,000%
Imagine if you had sold in 2014 because you thought the growth story was over
Learning the hard way I learned this lesson firsthand, earlier in my career
I've written the several times, but the general idea is that I made a modest investment of 100 s in Tesla (TSLA -0. 52%) at $23, shortly after its IPO in 2011, and sold in late 2013 to help pay for my wedding
At the time, the then-new Model S had just been named "Car of the Year" by Motor Trend, and the stock had nearly tripled from the price I paid
However, I could have certainly paid for my wedding in other ways, such as with the AT&T (T -0. 72%) stock I had decided to hang on to instead
And if I had held my Tesla stock, it would have been a grand slam run
Tesla has split twice since I sold, once 5-for-1 and again at 3-for-1, so my original 100 s would now be 1,500 s
The current price is $292 per, so my $2,300 investment would be worth $438,000 today if I had held on
A valuable principle Of course, this was a tough lesson to learn, but it's one that has served me well in the 12 years since
To be sure, I still sell stocks occasionally, but for the right reasons
For example, I recently sold a stock because its growth unexpectedly slowed down
On the other hand, when I sold Tesla, the company had been doing exactly what I hoped it would, or even better
The only reason I sold is that the price went up and I decided to take a fit
For this reason, I'm sitting on large gains in the Bank of America (BAC -0. 70%) stock I bought just after the financial crisis, the Block (XYZ 1. 68%) s I scooped up shortly after its IPO for $10, and the s of real estate investment trust Ryman Hospitality perties (RHP 0. 02%) that have been nearly a ten-bagger since I bought at the depths of the COVID-19 pandemic
There are other examples as well, but the point is that I've learned to let my winners keep winning
Hopefully this helps you learn it as well without repeating my Tesla mistake
Bank of America is an advertising partner of Motley Fool Money
Matt Frankel has positions in Bank of America, Block, Ryman Hospitality perties, and Starbucks
The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Bank of America, Block, Nvidia, Starbucks, and Tesla
The Motley Fool recommends Ryman Hospitality perties
The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
Related Articles
More insights from FinancialBooklet