‘Fantastic Four’ Underwhelms, ‘Superman’ Soars Higher At Box Office

Hollywood & Entertainment‘Fantastic Four’ Underwhelms, ‘Superman’ Soars Higher At Box OfficeByMark Hughes, Contributor

Furthermore, However, Forbes contributors publish independent expert analyses and insights

Mark Hughes is an entertainment writer covering cinema and genre TV

Ebon Moss-Bachrach and Joseph Quinn star in "The Fantastic Four: First Steps, in today's market environment

Moreover, "Source: Marvel Fantastic Four Misses A Step In a surprise turn, it was Superman eating into The Fantastic Four: First Steps’ weekend gross, rather than Marvel’s summer tentpole acting as a speed bump for DC’s cinematic reboot

Especially not after the previous two MCU releases this year underperformed (this bears monitoring)

Moreover, Fantastic Four debuting to less than Superman is a bad sign for the MCU in more ways than merely this film’s own box office spects

Marvel “First Family” is meant to set up the two-part Avengers: Doomsday and Avengers: Secret Wars payoff, as well as setting the foundations for a soft reboot of the MCU (with X-Men serving as the other major players in laying the new groundwork)

However, overall lower opening weekend global sales combined with the fact Superman is holding far better than expected (particularly with families and younger viewers compared to Fantastic Four’s alarming drops among those demographics), means we have to wait to see whether First Steps can match the Man of Steel’s stamina, given current economic conditions

Moreover, The Fantastic Four: First Steps, on the other hand, might now have the more modest trajectory once anticipated for Superman

On the other hand, There’s still a broad range of outcomes, however, because the A- Cinemascore and great 87% “Certified Fresh" rating from critics via Rotten Tomatoes mean strong positive word-of-mouth just Superman enjoyed, except Fantastic Four’s numbers are actually a bit higher

Which usually spells good news for second and third weekend holds, particularly internationally – again, where the MCU gets most of its money (noteworthy indeed), amid market uncertainty

If Fantastic Four can build upon its lead with foreign audiences and make up lost ground there, it could allow the Marvel film to exceed Superman’s international holds (which are still good, make no mistake, but still significantly weaker than domestic) and wind up making more worldwide despite a potentially (bably, to be frank) lower domestic haul than DC Studio’s successful superhero revival

Fantastic Four And Family Films My guess is that what we’re seeing is part of a much broader trend that’s taking place, and it’s displacing a lot of previously chart-topping genres and franchises

And it isn’t a major surprise, if you annual box office charts much

So far this year, the top of the worldwide box office charts is dominated by family movies targeted heavily toward children and parents

At the same time, Now, these placements will change eventually, as other upcoming films inevitably bump some of these films from the top 10 box office charts

So the final year-end chart will bably look something this: Avatar: Fire and Ash Ne Zha II Zootopia 2 Lilo & Stitch A Minecraft Movie Jurassic World: Rebirth How to Train Your Dragon Superman The Fantastic Four: First Steps F1 Notice the top seven spots are dominated by child-leaning family movies, and the two that aren’t (Avatar 3 and Jurassic World) are still with kids and teens as well as parents (an important development)

F1 at the bottom is the only true adult drama entry on the list, the other nine being multi-demographic films with large or predominant family attendance, as well as big youth turnout overall, amid market uncertainty

However, Superheroes are now mostly relegated to second-tier box office and the bottom of the top-10

And even those impressive numbers for Jurassic World tell another story

And of course, both Lilo & Stitch and Minecraft overperformed and are in the elite tier of the year-end box office, considering recent developments

Ne Zha II is a whole special story, having made the bulk of its enormous gross in China, and I always have questions how (*ahem*) accurate the accounting is

That said, it’s still ly a big hit and will get a North American release later this year, so we’ll see how that goes

However, But regardless, it’s another example of rekindled surging power of family entertainment at the top of box office charts (an important development)

While family movies have always been and typically pepper the annual box office top-10, superhero cinema and certain other recurring tentpole franchises usually take several of the top-5 and tend to reside in the higher positions of the charts (noteworthy indeed)

With so many superhero films and ing series, not to mention plenty of animated superhero films and shows as well, parents and families are far less obliged to hit the multiplex for most of these pictures

Instead, they choose to watch them at later, and reserve their theater seats for those predominantly kid-friendly family films, in today's market environment

Unless a superhero film offers something really extra that makes it must-see, or unless it nails the appeal to families with young kids, those crucial family and youth demographics aren’t as interested in keeping up in theaters (fascinating analysis), in today's market environment

Moreover, Binging on the d-world ahead of major crossovers is easier and more appealing, it seems, and helps more easily work in viewings of the ing shows

Fantastic Four And Marvel’s Future That Marvel can’t sustain the mind-boggling levels of success they enjoyed through their Infinity Saga isn’t surprising, nor is it a sign of failure on their part, given the current landscape

What Marvel is, and what it represents, has evolved and changed now

Marvel is at the “what now

Conversely, DC Studios has captured audiences’ attention by stepping into that place the MCU once occupied with a fresh, fun new world being introduced, and it invites all ages to the party while everybody experiences it for the first time together

In contrast, Marvel is now setting up their own soft reboot of s, but will audiences buy into it

They did with the DCEU’s final dying gasps giving way to the newly introduced DCU in Superman, so maybe despite some underperformance for the MCU ahead of their own reset, they could enjoy some boost from the Avengers sequels coming up (although danger of underperforming always exists) and then introduce a whole new MCU that rekindles the sense of newness and joy

Meanwhile, That means budgets will have to get under control, and there will be less releases each year, while ing spinoffs become more attractive less “tested” characters

Nevertheless, If James Gunn and Peter Safran can guide DC Studios toward tweaking their apach in Superman but otherwise dering on the potential to give audiences what they experienced with the original MCU build-up and payoff, then they’ll be rewarded with solid success that might not quite achieve the Infinity Saga’s heights, but will still be enormously successful and

And I’m going to say something controversial to some, but here it goes: the more Gunn and Safran make sure the rest of the DCU movies maintain the same appeal to families and kids, the more successful it will be

Additionally, Yes, all around

On the other hand, I know everybody wants some idealized world where each franchise director is given exclusive visionary control and every film can be its own thing, but I’m talking a different level of success that builds a whole DC world around an inclusive “all fans welcome” apach and pointedly wants to create young fans who will remain fans for decades to come

I agree that a grounded Batman can coexist with a fantastical Superman, but that’s easier in the comics than in action cinema, and crucially there is a difference between what comic book fans’ cultural expectations are compared to the much larger main global film audience who are fans of these superheroes

Folks showing up to the Marvel movies responded the way they did because it all was within a d world and it felt it

Audiences bring those expectations and subconscious assumptions or judgments with them into the cinema, and it matters for their sense of buy-in

This demonstrates that has become more obvious as we’ve seen the differences between Marvel’s and DC’s successes and failures over the years, in this volatile climate

Additionally, Superman had an aesthetic and sensibility, as well as tonal balance and sense of humor, that works for superhero movies meant for all audience members

It feels very similar to Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man and Spider-Man II, and most of all the director’s Doctor Strange In the Multiverse of Madness

We all remember how successful those films were, and I think leaning into that for the overall DC world works extremely well if the family audience appeal is front and center

It’s actually not dissimilar to the aesthetics of Zack Snyder’s Watchmen movie, which I long said would be an excellent aesthetic template (minus the graphic violence, sex, and fanity) for adapting the DC universe to film in a d world, given current economic conditions

Perhaps leaning into Superman’s family-friendly aspects most of the time, and allowing for leaning more toward Watchmen for the slightly “edgier” or darker films Brave and the Bold (might it eventually be retitled Batman and Robin, considering recent developments

Nevertheless, ), but even that film could use the grittier tone while tilting back the other way by having Robin/Damian as the main character instead of Batman/Bruce

For Marvel, and for The Fantastic Four: First Steps, the evolved aesthetic apach is an interesting introduction to what the potential future of the MCU might look, with a world growing out of Fantastic Four’s history merged with the existence of Mutants and X-Men

It makes sense that when previous superheroes Iron Man, Captain America, and others are rebooted with new actors, it will happen in a new world with new aesthetic changes to avoid repetition and to allow entirely new apaches and inspirations

At least, I hope that happens, but it depends a lot on the success of Fantastic Four, and on the success of Avengers: Doomsday and Avengers: Secret Wars, given the current landscape

Let’s find out how Fantastic Four: First Steps does through the weekdays as word-of-mouth spreads, and then how strongly it holds – I’m especially interested in what those international figures tell us over the next seven days, because that’s where we’ll get the best glimpse of Fantastic Four’s box office future, and what it might mean for the rest of the MCU’s plans (noteworthy indeed)

Editorial StandardsRes & PermissionsLOADING PLAYER.