A new piece of Wall Street research prompted us to change our rating on Salesforce
Key Takeaways
Melius Research's downgrade of Adobe makes the case that AI is a major threat to software providers like Salesforce.
Article Overview
Quick insights and key information
7 min read
Estimated completion
real estate
Article classification
August 11, 2025
07:53 PM
CNBC
Original publisher
For the better part of the last decade, we've heard that software is eating the world
But now it seems AI is eating software
That's the call analysts at Melius Re are once again making Monday as they downgraded one-time market darling Adobe to a sell rating
The attention-grabbing note highlights the far-reaching ripple effects that artificial intelligence is having across the stock market — and investors must be attune. name Salesforce is in the crosshairs of the shifting landscape, and we cannot ignore that fact
It's a major reason why the stock and that of enterprise software peers Atlassian and Workday have struggled in 2025
In Melius' view, the rise of AI is to software what the rise of cloud computing was to on-premise data centers
Historically, companies would maintain their own data centers in-house, requiring massive investments in hardware and teams of engineers there to maintain and troubleshoot any issues
Today, however, companies can outsource this simply by hopping on the cloud computing bandwagon, utilizing the s of Amazon Web Services, Microsoft's Azure and Alphabet's Google Cloud
AWS became the first modern cloud service to launch in 2006
The rise of the cloud was bad news for the stocks of on-premise hardware viders such as Dell , Hewlett-Packard and IBM
As this shift to cloud computing took hold, Melius noted that these companies all saw a steep contraction in their price-to-earnings multiples, a classic sign that investors believe slower growth is ahead. "Just when you thought the coast was , their PE multiples kept going lower and lower — from the 20s to mid-single digits," Melius wrote Monday. name Microsoft was also a key vider of software for on-premise servers
However, Microsoft did adjust its strategy with the launch of cloud service Azure
The cloud was a priority for CEO Satya Nadella upon taking over in early 2014, and it's paid off handsomely for investors — just take a look at the stock chart versus the S & P 500
MSFT .SPX mountain 2013-12-31 Microsoft's stock performance versus the S & P 500 since the start of 2014
Microsoft would have no doubt been on that list of on-premise fallen angels — even if not a hardware play Hewlett-Packard and Dell — had they not jumped on cloud computing and instead kept their fate tied to the on-premise hardware viders
Azure is the No. 2 cloud by revenue behind AWS and is seeing growth reaccelerate thanks to AI
The lesson from Microsoft: If you're model is being disrupted, you can still adapt, survive and thrive
However, if you're getting disrupted and fail to adapt, then the valuation that investors are willing to pay for your stock will reflect that failure
Instead, the investors will move on to owning the disruptors in question, which, in the present moment, are the AI players pushing into the software-as-a-service space
Often abbreviated as SaaS, this model was all the rage not too long ago itself
Instead of companies paying for a perpetual license to use a specific version of software, SaaS companies sold their duct on a subscription basis, bringing in a more predictable recurring revenue that investors were willing to assign a higher multiple
It often involves a "seat model," where companies pay based on the number of employees using the software
Melius believes it's under real threat. "We think companies are increasingly understanding that AI tools can help cut expensive knowledge workers with those costly SaaS seats
In fact, opex is going down as a percent of sales across leaders since the AI boom started
One of the ways they are doing it is reducing workers who typically are the biggest consumers of SaaS ... and Adobe could be impacted as other companies catch on," the Melius analysts wrote in their downgrade
They added, "We think there will be FOMO across all industries to cut costs and get their stocks up - SaaS is the casualty as AI adoption accelerates." To be sure, while this is a potential concern for Salesforce, plenty of other names in the portfolio stand to benefit
Among them are Microsoft and Amazon because their cloud services are enabling others to leverage AI
Indeed, the Melius analysts themselves contend: "While SaaS should be avoided, 'Software' companies with clouds [such as Microsoft and Oracle] are continuing to see acceleration in demand." "Another area fueling demand is the acceleration of AI agents that do the work of SaaS and fuel demand for more compute," Melius added
Agentic AI is a type of AI system that can complete certain tasks without human intervention, and it's become a big area of investment and focus in the AI race — including for Salesforce
In that way, Salesforce occupies both sides of a tricky situation
It's both a SaaS company and a company that's recognized how transformative AI can be
That's why we were torn as we read Melius' re Monday
On the one hand, we think Melius makes some pretty good points
After all, we are seeing companies do more with less thanks to generative and agentic AI
And given that SaaS is generally based on the seat-based licensing model, if Salesforce's customers have fewer employees because their remaining ones are using AI to be more ductive, that translates to less demand for software seats — all else being equal
We also do believe AI is a once-in-a lifetime nology that will have implications far wider reaching than the shift to cloud did over the past decade
On the other hand, Salesforce in particular remains a critical tool for companies across industries and a best-in-class vider when it comes to customer relationship management (CRM) software
Salesforce also isn't standing idly by
Instead, the company is working to build out its agentic AI offering, appriately dubbed Agentforce, so that it can help clients move more quickly into the AI era, while also building out a new AI-oriented revenue that can hopefully help extract more revenue from those seats at customers that do remain
Un Adobe, it's also important to keep in mind that Salesforce is targeted almost exclusively toward enterprise, where the customer cohort tends to be more sticky and a bit slower to change things up, lest they risk a misstep that hurts sales
While Salesforce isn't alone in offering tools to build Agents — Microsoft, which competes with Salesforce in the CRM arena, also has them — the company ly has a strategy
In the end, we aren't ready to bail on Salesforce just yet, though we understand the market's concern with the SaaS space
Salesforce is still a great house, but the neighborhood is deteriorating
And as any good real estate agent will tell you, it's location that matters above all
As a result, we're downgrading s of Salesforce to a hold-equivalent 2 rating as we look to better understand to what extent Salesforce is being disrupted, or if can indeed adapt to the new world
While the stock is already down a lot this year, and we believe in the management team, it's the of in the numbers that we need to see before getting more optimistic. (Jim Cramer's Charitable Trust is long CRM
See here for a full list of the stocks.) As a r to the CNBC with Jim Cramer, you will receive a trade alert before Jim makes a trade
Jim waits 45 minutes after sending a trade alert before buying or selling a stock in his charitable trust's portfolio
If Jim has talked a stock on CNBC TV, he waits 72 hours after issuing the trade alert before executing the trade
THE ABOVE INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO OUR TERMS AND CONDITIONS AND PRIVACY POLICY , TOGETHER WITH OUR DISCLAIMER
NO FIDUCIARY OBLIGATION OR DUTY EXISTS, OR IS CREATED, BY VIRTUE OF YOUR RECEIPT OF ANY INFORMATION VIDED IN CONNECTION WITH THE
NO SPECIFIC OUTCOME OR FIT IS GUARANTEED.
Related Articles
More insights from FinancialBooklet